Insights:Why Competitor Research Falls Flat (And How to Fix It)
Four-Step Troubleshooting
Step 1: Check if Conclusions Have Been Formed
- Are there no more than three clear judgments?
- Can each judgment be traced back to a specific page or pricing action?
If there are no conclusions, the issue lies in the research phase.
Step 2: Check if Conclusions Have Been Claimed
- Does each recommendation specify an owner and a deadline?
- Has it entered the schedule or task backlog?
If nothing has been claimed, the issue lies in the handoff phase.
Step 3: Check if Actions Have Been Executed
- Were the recommended pages actually changed?
- Were pricing or service scope adjusted?
If there's no execution, the issue lies in the priority phase.
Step 4: Check if Data Was Collected After Execution
- Is there before-and-after comparison data?
- Are there post-mortem records?
If nothing was collected, future research will still rely on intuition.
Common Breakpoint Reference
| Symptom | Breakpoint | Remedy |
|---|---|---|
| "We've done research" but can't state conclusions | Research | Mandatory output of 3 judgments |
| Conclusions exist but no one takes ownership | Handoff | Write as tasks and assign owners |
| Tasks exist but never get scheduled | Priority | Tie to quarterly objectives |
| Work gets done but effectiveness is unknown | Collection | Set up baseline data before changes |
When to Stop
- If two consecutive research cycles produce no executable actions: stop first, fix the process.
A Quick Reminder
Competitor research isn't about "getting to know the competition" — it's about "deciding what you'll do." There's only one yardstick: has it actually changed your actions?
Scope
This article addresses cases where research was already done but implementation fell short. If you haven't started yet, begin with process- and checklist-style guides instead of diving into data collection right away.
Related Reading: