Insights:How to Choose Between Competitive and Market Research: 3 Approaches
Path 1: Page-Level Breakdown
Approach: Go through each competitor's service pages, case study pages, and FAQs one by one, and note whether they include pricing, timelines, and comparisons.
- Best for: When you are preparing to redesign or rewrite service pages.
- Cost: 1–2 days, one person can complete it.
- Can answer: What information competitors show on their pages, and what we are missing.
- Limits: Cannot see real conversion data.
Path 2: Keyword-Level Comparison
Approach: Collect the keywords competitors cover, compare them with your own, and identify gaps.
- Best for: Content planning and topic selection phases.
- Cost: 2–3 days, requires a keyword tool.
- Can answer: Which needs are already covered, and which areas are blank.
- Limits: Keyword volume does not equal demand size; judgment is required.
Path 3: Customer-Level Interviews
Approach: Interview both closed-won and lost customers to understand who they compared you against and why they chose you (or didn't).
- Best for: Teams with an existing customer base looking to uncover real differentiators.
- Cost: 1–2 weeks, requires sales team involvement.
- Can answer: What customers truly care about at the point of decision.
- Limits: Small sample size; conclusions should be extrapolated cautiously.
Comparison of Three Paths
| Dimension | Page Breakdown | Keyword Comparison | Customer Interview |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Low | Medium | High |
| Timeline | 1–2 days | 2–3 days | 1–2 weeks |
| Confidence of Conclusions | Medium | Medium | High |
| Actionability | High (direct page editing) | High (direct topic selection) | Medium (requires action conversion) |
| Applicable Stage | Before Redesign | Content Planning | Positioning Adjustment |
How to Combine
- Early stage: Page breakdown + keyword comparison to quickly generate topics and renovation checklists.
- After building a client base: Add client interviews to calibrate earlier findings.
- Quarterly: Re-run keyword comparisons to check if competitors have new coverage.
Three Questions When Choosing
- Are you missing "content topics" or "page information"? The former goes through keywords, the latter through page breakdown.
- Do you have clients available for interviews? If not, skip the interview planning path.
- How tight is your decision timeline? If tight, start with the low-cost approach first.
Common Mistakes
- Only doing page breakdowns and arriving at useless conclusions like "competitor pages look better."
- Only doing keyword comparisons and producing a list of topics nobody searches for.
- Taking a 2-person interview sample as market consensus.
Boundaries
All three approaches are "external observations" and cannot replace internal data (inquiry records, transaction records). The most reliable research cross-validates external observation with internal data.
Related Reading: