7 Most Common Mistakes with Domains and DNS

Domain and DNS incidents are rarely caused by complex technology—they usually come down to skipped basics. These seven pitfalls are ranked by frequency, each wi…

Insights:7 Most Common Mistakes with Domains and DNS

Pitfall 1: Only Changed One NS

Impact: Intermittent DNS resolution — results vary by region, making them hard to reproduce during troubleshooting.

Cause: Registrars usually require two or more NS records; changing only one leaves the old provider's servers still responding.

Check: Run dig NS domain to inspect the returned list, confirm all entries point to the new provider, and verify each NS resolves correctly.

Pitfall 2: Didn't Lower TTL Before Changing IP

Impact: Old IP cache hasn't expired yet, so some users keep hitting the old server; if the old server is already shut down, those visitors see a blank page or 502 error.

Cause: The TTL remained at 24 hours or more, leading to the assumption that the record update takes effect immediately.

Check: Lower the TTL at least one full TTL cycle before switching servers; after updating, watch the old server's logs and confirm traffic has stopped before decommissioning it.

Pitfall 3: Configured Only www, Not the Root Domain

Impact: Visitors who type the address without www can't reach the site, or they're served a different website instead.

Cause: An A or CNAME record was set up for www only, leaving the root domain without any record.

Check: Access both the root domain and www; confirm one does a 301 redirect to the other; ensure both with and without a trailing slash resolve to the same address.

Pitfall 4: Placing a CNAME Directly on the Root Domain

Impact: Some resolvers reject it, causing conflicts with mail and verification records, leading to unstable DNS behavior.

Cause: By DNS standards, a CNAME is not appropriate at the root (apex) domain; while some providers work around this with ALIAS/ANAME, support isn't universal.

Check: Use A/AAAA for the root domain; if your provider supports ALIAS, follow their docs; don't force a plain CNAME onto the apex.

Pitfall 5: Conflicting MX and SPF records

Impact: Can receive but not send mail, or messages land in spam; in severe cases the entire domain is flagged as forged.

Cause: Switched email providers but left old MX records; multiple SPF TXT records coexist; DKIM not configured.

Check: Keep only the current provider's MX records; retain a single SPF record; configure DKIM per provider instructions; set DMARC to monitoring first, then tighten.

Pitfall 6: Certificate covers only one domain

Impact: The main domain works fine, but www or subdomains show certificate errors; users see the warning and leave immediately.

Cause: Only a single-domain certificate was issued, or the certificate chain is incomplete.

Check: Visit the main domain, www, and all common subdomains; confirm the cert chain is complete and set expiry reminders; ensure HTTP redirects to HTTPS via 301.

Pitfall 7: No ownership of expiration and accounts

Impact: Domain expires and DNS stops resolving, possibly getting snapped up by others; renewal alerts go to an unchecked inbox.

Cause: Domain is registered under a former employee's account; renewal notices are sent only to a personal email; no second person has access to act.

Check: Register the domain under an organizational account; enable two-factor authentication; record expiration dates well in advance; grant at least two people operational access; rotate passwords after transfer.

Troubleshooting order when issues arise

Start with NS and A/AAAA, then check TTL and cache, and finally inspect certificates and email. Don't jump straight into changing records—first capture the current resolution output so you have a reference for rollback.

Related reading: